Since U Been Sued: The Art of the Bad Review

Table of Contents

Since U Been Sued: The Art of the Bad Review

A little $15,000 mechanical birdie told me that you were curious about how to handle bad Google or Yelp reviews. What if…let’s say…you piss off a high-profile American Idol winner and she takes to the internet to bash your niche Brooklyn novelty shop? Social media, meet the Streisand Effect.

But in all seriousness, while bad reviews can be incredibly damaging, not all bad reviews are created equal, and the options for handling them are more limited than people think. What doesn’t kill your business might still cost you in legal fees.

Your Business Has Been Defamed. Now What?

Imagine someone with a substantial social media following makes a damaging accusation about your business. Your first instinct might be to call your attorney, draft a cease and desist letter, and demand that the offending post disappear. But what if the statement is true? Even if you disagree with the review, believe it was based on a misunderstanding, or feel it left out important context, it’s an uphill and expensive battle if you can’t prove that the underlying statement itself was false.

So, I’m sorry folks, but a review accusing your employee of being a condescending jerk and treating your customer like Vivian Ward in Pretty Woman is a subjective opinion, not necessarily a concrete statement of fact. Even if we are dealing with a false statement of fact, you really need to make sure you have proper documentation and preservation of evidence procedures in place. Failing to thoroughly investigate what happened, assess the economic impact, and preserve relevant records before deciding on your next move can be a big mistake. Huge.

Defamation’s Less Famous Cousin: Disparagement

Here’s another legal concept that doesn’t get nearly as much attention: business disparagement, sometimes referred to as trade libel or injurious falsehood.

While defamation generally involves injury to reputation, business disparagement typically focuses on false statements that damage the economic interests of a business, its products, or its services. These claims often require proof of a false statement, the applicable level of fault or malice, and specific financial losses.

For example, imagine a competitor falsely announces that your company is shutting down or that your products are unsafe. If customers cancel orders or business partners terminate relationships as a result, there may be a basis for a business disparagement claim.

But here’s the issue. Being upset about a statement and its fallout is one thing; proving that the statement was made with the requisite malice and actually caused economic damage is another entirely.

A decline in sales might be relevant. Lost contracts or canceled orders may be relevant. Hating that thousands of teenagers on TikTok are making fun of your business…not so much.

Before You Threaten to Sue, Meet the Streisand Effect

For anyone unfamiliar with the Streisand Effect, it’s the phenomenon where attempting to suppress information inadvertently draws considerably more attention to it. The phenomenon was named after Barbra Streisand’s famously unsuccessful effort to suppress an aerial photograph of her home.

Let’s say someone posts a negative review about your business. A few people see it. You immediately clap back with a strongly worded legal threat and throw in a few choice insults for good measure. Now someone screenshots your letter or review response. The original poster shares it. Other people weigh in. Suddenly, what might have been a forgettable complaint has become a story about a company allegedly trying to silence its critics.

A Bird in the Hand Is Worth How Much in Legal Fees?

Sometimes legal intervention is absolutely appropriate, especially when false factual allegations are actually harming your business. Before adding fuel to the fire, put your public relations hat on and figure out if there’s a better, less expensive way.

For business owners, the lesson isn’t that you should sue everyone who leaves you a bad review. It’s that you should understand when criticism crosses a legal line, what evidence you’ll need to establish that it did, and whether pursuing a legal remedy actually serves your business interests. Because sometimes, the smartest legal move isn’t necessarily filing a lawsuit.

Whether you’re trying to protect your business’s reputation or avoid turning a PR nightmare into a legal one, as always, if you’ve got questions, you know we’ve got answers!

~ The W + K Team

ABOUT WEINSTEIN + KLEIN P.C.

Founded in 2019, Weinstein + Klein is a modern boutique law firm that serves as outside general counsel to businesses across industries. Weinstein + Klein provides strategic, day-to-day legal support with a focus on labor and employment law, corporate and transactional matters, and business litigation. Weinstein + Klein works closely with business owners, executives, and entrepreneurs to proactively manage risk, navigate complex employment issues, and handle key transactions – from formation to funding to exit.

Spark Discussion on Facebook
Tweet to Foster Business Wisdom
Share with your Professional Network
« »
A law firm where professional meets personable. That’s us.